First trip to Key West for my wife and I to celebrate our anniversary. Conch Cottage was the perfect spot to call home on our stay. Centrally located on the island and just a block from Duval Street. We will be back for sure.

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: First off, Angie with Preferred Properties is absolutely incredible and went above and beyond to accommodate my husband and I when we found ourself in need of last minute accommodations. I really can’t say enough about how fantastic she was! Outside of that, the home had absolutely everything we needed and was in the perfect location to walk to everything. It has an amazing intimate fenced in back yard with a great jacuzzi. If you are thinking of booking, think no more, BOOK IT!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was more than satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: This was our second time at this property in the past few years, and the owners have been right on top of taking care of the property. When something wears out, they replace it to keep the property attractive.

The property is wonderful, and we loved everything about the clean, comfortable cottage. The location was great. The private back patio with the hot tub and outdoor shower was amazing. We’ve never worked with Preferred Properties before, but they were awesome and we highly recommend them!!

The property is wonderful, and we loved everything about the clean, comfortable cottage. The location was great. The private back patio with the hot tub and outdoor shower was amazing. We’ve never worked with Preferred Properties before, but they were awesome and we highly recommend them!!

Place was awesome, and location allowed us to walk almost everywhere in the old town and waterfront areas. Parking can be difficult, but rarely used the car. Unless driving down from Miami, I would recommend no car. just walk, bike or scooter. Manager was great to deal with. Quick responses and helpful.

Had a great time. Property was very clean and right in the heart of key west.

Perfect location. Walkable to Duval street restaurants and shopping. Backyard patio very well done. No real grass area for dogs, but there’s a church yard right across the street that we used for potty breaks. Great communication with the company. Loved staying there!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: Beautiful place to stay and close to everything in key west

Great place to stay! We would do it again tomorrow.

The location is perfect. Nothing was too far of a walk but I'd recommend a bike or cart rental. The rental was clean but the floors need a good scrub. The AC doesn't work super well but we managed. The dryer does not work so I wouldn't depend on it for your stay. Nothing serious but I'd consider it if you plan on booking. Everything else about this rental was perfect. The outdoor space was our favorite part. Water pressure is better outside! Bed is SUPER comfortable. Kitchen was awesome, had to run the dishwasher twice but it got the dishes clean after the second run. Would stay again in a heartbeat!!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: Great place. Awesome location and place for a trip to Key West.

Small cottage but has all you need for a comfortable stay for 1 or 2 people. Best part is the completely private backyard and the outdoor shower and hottub.

We had a great stay at Conch Cottage. The location is convenient and quiet (other than just a little street noise and some local roosters). The outdoor shower was our favorite amenity! The house isn’t new, but it’s well taken care of and clean. The property management company’s communication was awesome.

Great location! Reasonably priced. Clean, safe neighborhood. Easy to get around.

Very easy communication with property management. Cannot beat the location right in the middle of everything. We were worried parking would be difficult but we found street parking fairly close with no issue. Great spot in key west!

We absolutely loved staying in this sweet little place just 2 blocks down from Duval. It had absolutely everything we needed and the property management team was awesome. This was our 25th wedding anniversary and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Our favorite amenity was the out door shower...magical!

This cottage was as advertised. Great location , short walk to Duval St,. Located on a quiet street.

This is our 2nd stay at The Conch Cottage and we loved it just as much this time as the first. The location is perfect (just off Duval), it’s clean and comfy, the backyard is your own private oasis and the outdoor shower is amazing! We will be returning!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: This little cottage was perfect for my husband and I during our anniversary trip to Key West! It’s cute, with everything you could need. It’s so close to busy Duvall Street but still quiet with lots of privacy for relaxation. Preferred Property was wonderful and made themselves available for any questions or needs, they even surprised us with a bottle of champagne and a note wishing us a Happy Anniversary! Absolutely recommend! You won’t be disappointed!

Booked this primarily for the walkable location which is 110% perfect! Some reviews make note of noise however was not a problem for us at night as we closed the doors from the bedroom and bathroom; and we are LIGHT sleepers. Otherwise yes; you can hear traffic/people very clearly in the home however I am sure that is the same or norm in many more homes this old. Super clean property and plenty of kitchen extras if you feel the need to cook. Not so great moments or items......the mattress was not great however the owners have since ordered a new one which was coming in last night before we checked out. Hot tub; only half of it worked. Both of these two items we only found out half way through our stay NOT before. The last two mornings of our stay we had a random gardener company using a leaf blower and trimmers on the back deck at 8am and another gentleman running/checking hot tub. Notification of random people showing up would of went a long ways as we clearly didnt get to sleep in our last two mornings needless to say they saw us sleeping! Toliet paper; is limited and not noted until you get there on the welcome book. For a 8 night stay; we got 3 skinny rolls which I've never had experienced prior to this stay and more so at this price point. Great location and super clean; we just felt a bit cheated based on the money we spent for 8 nights which isn't cheap.

This is our second time at Conch Cottage and for sure won’t be our last. It is the cutest house with a perfect location. It has everything you need. We felt like we were home.

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: We have stayed 2 times at the Conch Cottage. The place is great, the location is excellent, the management company is wonderful! Special shout out to Angela, so helpful. Only downside is no ice maker. 100+ degrees and we had to use plastic ice trays to make ice. Please get an icemaker!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: I've visited Key West many times, and this visit was one of the best. If this cottage had off-street parking, it would be the best rental ever! For a couple, it's perfect. The location couldn't be better. We'd definitely stay here again. One small observation, though: The mattress might be nearing the end of its life or need an upgrade. Overall, fantastic.

This house was so lovely and very well stocked with everything we needed. My husband and I spent a few days here for our 25th anniversary and loved it. The outdoor space is wonderful and very private. The location was also nice for us. We walked everywhere we wanted to go, but the home is far enough away from the hustle of the night life, that it was very peaceful. Highly recommend!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: My husband and I stayed here and it was amazing! We were able to get into the house no problem. It was clean, and fully stocked with linens, kitchen gadgets & cookware. Right in the center of KeyWest. Backyard oasis was a major bonus! Will def be back! Management went above & beyond. LOVED OUR STAY

Have stayed here several times. Love the house and location. Management always helpful.

This property was absolutely perfect for two people. The space was just enough, and we used the outside patio everyday. It is close to Duval action, but super quiet. Everything was effortless from check in to check out. Could not say enough about this property!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: The house was exactly as described. Everything was clean and very well organized. The management company was quick to respond to any question or request. Highly, highly, highly recommended. We will be back!

This property was absolutely perfect for two people. The space was just enough, and we used the outside patio everyday. It is close to Duval action, but super quiet. Everything was effortless from check in to check out. Could not say enough about this property!

We come to KW often and have stayed in many different properties. We always stay in Old Town within a few blocks of the location of Conch Cottage. We walk or ride bikes everywhere, so the central location of the cottage is perfect. Things were exactly as advertised. The cottage is a perfect spot for a couple to have their own getaway. The very private back patio area w/hot tub, lounges, eating area and outdoor shower was perfect. Pack light, the washer and dryer come in real handy. This could be a go-to place for our visits for sure.

Nice little cottage, surprisingly quiet. Only a few blocks away from Duval Street and was within walking distance to downtown. So convenient. Comfy bed, good shower and perfect temp. A couple improvements…Jacuzzi was too hot and took long time to get it so it was safe. The step to get in was unsafe because of slippage. Would recommend putting something to stop it from sliding. But overall a delightful place.