The Simonton is like a hidden treasure, it doesn't look like much from the outside but you enter & it is like a magical hidden gem of victorian times.

We love this property. It’s incredibly beautiful. The staff is overly friendly and amazing. I’ve stayed here twice and will continues to stay here everytime I come back. Everyone is so nice. Jonathan and violet are some of the nicest people I’ve met.

Friendly staff!!!!!

One of the best stays I’ve had in Key West - we’ll likely stay here for all future stays

Beautiful, historic with friendly staff. Close to activities but quiet as well.

Best location, staff, service and overall place to stay in the keys

The location is great. It is very close to Durval St. The hotel is beautiful with a lot of trees. I rented bikes and went to the beaches. The staff is amazing. Jonathan and Eric were very friendly. The room was super clean and cozy. I will come back.

We absolutely enjoyed our stay! It was perfect and we will definitely recommend Simonton Court Historic Inn to everyone! Thank you!

Beautiful property, nice amenities, professional and courteous staff.

The room was clean and neat, everyone is very friendly and helpful. So glad we booked this place last minute. The best time we've ever had in Key west. You will not get anything more authentic than this place. Loved it!

Amazing boutique hotel. Clean comfortable and great rates. Staff were great

The Staff was amazing!

The perfect place to spend a weekend getaway!

Wow! This will be our go-to for future KW stays. Perfect location. Beautiful grounds and room. Super comfortable. But really, it’s the people. From our first interactions over the phone setting up scooter rental, to the personal texts we got as our arrival neared to the front desk help radiating genuine happiness and helpfulness to the young lady helping us with breakfast: 12 out of 10. This is the kind of environment and friendly service that the world needs more of. Thank you, all of you. Can’t wait to get back!

Excellent stay. Beautiful and conveniently located. Jonathan and Eric very helpful and friendly. Note: parking on site is limited and costs $30 per night. Would stay again!

Jonathan and staff was excellent! We enjoyed the balcony view to the pool area!

The staff was friendly. We were upgraded to a deluxe room which was beautiful. There was no parking available onsite due to them being fully booked; however, they gave us a map to a parking lot that was about a 10 min walk and was $15 a night. Easy walk to Mallory Square.

Staff is amazing and so personable especially Jonathan!! Recommend this place to anyone who will listen.

It was nice and clean so beautiful full of greenery. All staff we came in contact with were nice and helpful when we needed help. This is my second visit to this establishment and I highly recommend it to anyone who wants a peaceful place to rest their heads on vacation.

Exceptional location. We were able to walk or bike everywhere! Lots of trees on the property made it extremely lush. Room was on a high floor. No elevators. Room door was extremely sticky and difficult to close and open the door. Thus it was loud. The bed is a little hard. We loved the ability to rent a bike for 24 hours. Best part they pump cool water into the pools during the hottest summer days!!!!

Exceptional location. We were able to walk or bike everywhere! Lots of trees on the property made it extremely lush. Our room was on the 3rd floor. No elevators. Our door was extremely sticky and difficult to close and open the door. Thus it was loud. The bed is a little hard. We loved the ability to rent a bike for 24 hours. Best part they pump cool water into the pools during the hottest summer days!!!!

Property was immaculate. The staff was wonderful. Will definitely be back.

Great property with multiple pools, great breakfast and attentive staff. Only negative was smoke detector went of/malfunctioned and wasn't resolved quickly. Will stay here again hopefully......

Pros: Overall the property was very charming. Cute pools and cottages. Landscape was very pretty and lush. It was nice to have a breakfast option, but the options were slim, but enough. Location is good and very close to everything. They offer filtered cold water which is nice not to have to buy water bottles. They offer happy hour art classes and the teacher--Eric is fantastic! Very fun perk! Cons: At first glance it looks clean, but when you start to look closer, not very clean. Could use a good deep clean. There are a lot of things falling apart or in disrepair. Many projects that could really make this place shine and feel more upscale and fresh. Some staff seemed kinda putout and a bit cynical-- not as service friendly as we hoped--especially for the price - others were fantastic. Parking is a hike if you don't buy on site - but I guess that is Key West for you.

Beautiful historic location. Very quiet with a friendly staff and clean rooms. Would definitely stay again.

Everyone was very helpful, very nice room

The staff was awesome, the property super cute!!

CONVENIENT, CLEAN, OASIS IN A BUSY TOWN

The staff were very friendly. Breakfast was great.

Simonton Court was a nice place to stay in close walking distance to everything. It felt safe and quiet and the staff were all excellent. We even got an upgrade for my 50th birthday and daily text checking on our needs. The villa we had was very nice but not excellent. The a/c and ceiling fans wouldn't keep up with the heat so at night it was stuffy when going to bed. The floor in the main living space is rotting and needs addressed. The wash clothes are so thin ghat you can literally see straight through. The bathroom vanity lighting is yellow and dim. The shower heads have a lot of build up and spray in every direction. The beds are average to a little firm. By one of the pools there is an ice machine and bottle filler which we used multiple times a day and tasted very good. There is a cat on property that they feed and keep around which is fine if you're a cat person, but if not, it's a little annoying. Overall, I would give the Simonton Court a 8.1 out of 10.

We had an amazing stay! Beautiful place! We loved our cottage! Comfortable with all the necessary amenities and excellent staff!

Simonton had the most amazing landscaping and four private pools