Iconic Mystic Mansion
4.9
Outstanding(63 Reviews)House in Stonington, CT
14 guests · 6 bedrooms · 7 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Includes essentialsGarden, Kitchen or Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Treat yourself to a genuinely unique experience in this luxurious six bedroom, six and a half bath rebuilt 19th century stone mansion overlooking Long Island Sound. Originally built in 1825 by Mystic banker Elias Brown the Stone House stood majestically atop Quoketaug Hill. Everything but the stonework burned to the ground in 1924. The family was finally able to realize their dream to rebuild it in 2016.
The formal living room with its marble-faced gas log fireplace offers a beautiful sitting area for quiet conversation, reading or watching television.
The dining room provides elegant seating for sixteen people. It too has a marble-faced gas-log fireplace. It is decorated with a beautiful collection of Japanese plates from the family’s years of living in Japan.
The gourmet kitchen features a 48” 6-burner gas stove with griddle and two ovens. The 3-seat granite topped peninsula area provides a work area with views of the verandah and Long Island Sound beyond. The kitchen is completely stocked with every cooking device required to create a gourmet meal. No need to tote things from home. A small breakfast nook makes a great place for early-risers to share a cup of coffee and watch the news. A Dutch door leads out to the verandah.
The 20’ by 24’ verandah offers alfresco dining in the warm weather. A gas grill is conveniently located just off the steps. Guests have easy access to the Garden Lot and wonderful views of Fisher’s Island.
Taking the stairs to the second floor you will find three bedroom suites. The Stanton Suite has a queen-sized bed and offers views to the south and east. The bath features a beautiful freestanding tub and a tile shower.
The Williams Suite is the largest bedroom and has a queen-sized bed. The windows face the hayfield to the east and offer views of Watch Hill in the distance.
The Denison Suite has a queen-size bed. Both the Williams and Denison suites have baths with custom tile showers.
All three 2nd floor bedrooms have remote operated gas-log fireplaces.
_____________________________________________________________________________
2ND FLOOR VERANDAH
The 2nd floor, 24' X 20' verandah offers beautiful views of the property, Fisher's Island and Long Island Sound. Watch the boats travel the sound while enjoying your morning coffee or an afternoon tea or cocktails. It is furnished with wicker furniture and rocking chairs. A 6-seat picnic table is a great place for lunch. See pictures below.
____________________________________________________________________________
The 3rd floor also has three bedroom suites. Two have beautiful walk-in tile showers. The third offers a tub/shower combo. The Harold and Marjory Suites have queen-size beds. The Einna Suite has two sets of bunk beds.
The largest part of the 3rd floor is given up to the Cottrell Room. This 25’ X 30’ south-facing room has two large sitting areas. The one in the south dormer has exquisite views. On clear days Montauk Point on the end of Long Island can be seen on the horizon. This is a great place for tea or cocktails and catching up with friends or family. The other is more of an entertainment area with a large flat-screen TV with a wrap-around couch to lounge around on. A premium cable package provides access to a vast selection of movies and sporting events There’s a game table for cards, chess or checkers. On the east side is a three-seat bar area with a sink, small refrigerator, ice maker, blender and enough glasses to make long trips to the kitchen unnecessary.
All the floors are hardwood except for the bathrooms which are tile. The laundry room in the basement has a washer and dryer for guests to use. There are individual heating and AC controls on each floor.
The house is situated on almost 6 acres of open fields. The driveway has ample parking for nine cars .We are less than 2 miles from Interstate 95 and less than 20 minutes from the casinos, wineries and Rhode Island beaches.
WE’RE VERY SORRY, BUT THE STONE HOUSE IS LOCATED IN A QUIET RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD, SO OUT OF RESPECT FOR OUR NEIGHBORS WE DO NOT ALLOW EVENTS OF MORE THAN THE FOURTEEN GUESTS (MAX) LODGING AT THE HOUSE.
The formal living room with its marble-faced gas log fireplace offers a beautiful sitting area for quiet conversation, reading or watching television.
The dining room provides elegant seating for sixteen people. It too has a marble-faced gas-log fireplace. It is decorated with a beautiful collection of Japanese plates from the family’s years of living in Japan.
The gourmet kitchen features a 48” 6-burner gas stove with griddle and two ovens. The 3-seat granite topped peninsula area provides a work area with views of the verandah and Long Island Sound beyond. The kitchen is completely stocked with every cooking device required to create a gourmet meal. No need to tote things from home. A small breakfast nook makes a great place for early-risers to share a cup of coffee and watch the news. A Dutch door leads out to the verandah.
The 20’ by 24’ verandah offers alfresco dining in the warm weather. A gas grill is conveniently located just off the steps. Guests have easy access to the Garden Lot and wonderful views of Fisher’s Island.
Taking the stairs to the second floor you will find three bedroom suites. The Stanton Suite has a queen-sized bed and offers views to the south and east. The bath features a beautiful freestanding tub and a tile shower.
The Williams Suite is the largest bedroom and has a queen-sized bed. The windows face the hayfield to the east and offer views of Watch Hill in the distance.
The Denison Suite has a queen-size bed. Both the Williams and Denison suites have baths with custom tile showers.
All three 2nd floor bedrooms have remote operated gas-log fireplaces.
_____________________________________________________________________________
2ND FLOOR VERANDAH
The 2nd floor, 24' X 20' verandah offers beautiful views of the property, Fisher's Island and Long Island Sound. Watch the boats travel the sound while enjoying your morning coffee or an afternoon tea or cocktails. It is furnished with wicker furniture and rocking chairs. A 6-seat picnic table is a great place for lunch. See pictures below.
____________________________________________________________________________
The 3rd floor also has three bedroom suites. Two have beautiful walk-in tile showers. The third offers a tub/shower combo. The Harold and Marjory Suites have queen-size beds. The Einna Suite has two sets of bunk beds.
The largest part of the 3rd floor is given up to the Cottrell Room. This 25’ X 30’ south-facing room has two large sitting areas. The one in the south dormer has exquisite views. On clear days Montauk Point on the end of Long Island can be seen on the horizon. This is a great place for tea or cocktails and catching up with friends or family. The other is more of an entertainment area with a large flat-screen TV with a wrap-around couch to lounge around on. A premium cable package provides access to a vast selection of movies and sporting events There’s a game table for cards, chess or checkers. On the east side is a three-seat bar area with a sink, small refrigerator, ice maker, blender and enough glasses to make long trips to the kitchen unnecessary.
All the floors are hardwood except for the bathrooms which are tile. The laundry room in the basement has a washer and dryer for guests to use. There are individual heating and AC controls on each floor.
The house is situated on almost 6 acres of open fields. The driveway has ample parking for nine cars .We are less than 2 miles from Interstate 95 and less than 20 minutes from the casinos, wineries and Rhode Island beaches.
WE’RE VERY SORRY, BUT THE STONE HOUSE IS LOCATED IN A QUIET RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD, SO OUT OF RESPECT FOR OUR NEIGHBORS WE DO NOT ALLOW EVENTS OF MORE THAN THE FOURTEEN GUESTS (MAX) LODGING AT THE HOUSE.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Stonington, CT
Reviews
4.9
Outstanding(63 Reviews)4.9
We had our inaugural couples weekend gateway! The house with three floors of spaciousness and gorgeous arrangements with warm and historical details made our experience even more memorable! We give our highest recommendations!
4.9
The house is beautiful. I brought dishes and bowls with me for serving chips and dip and such. I didn’t need any of it. I am very impressed that anything I could need was there!
We really enjoyed our stay.
4.9
This place was amazing beautiful views. Property was super clean it was like staying in a 5 star hotel. Everything was absolutely perfect. From coffee on the second floor porch to dinners around the enormous dining room table to late night snacks and games on the third floor. The hosts were so kind we will be back.
4.9
Our family will be staying here again!!
4.9
Wonderful property. Each room had its own bathroom. So much history and it felt like being in museum with stories about the original family. Kitchen was very well equipped. The dining room was spacious and could accommodate our whole group of 14 for all the meals. We loved it and would definitely come back.
4.9
We had a great stay at the Stone Mansion for our annual family reunion. Really a special house and place on the hill just outside old mystic. With 6 bedrooms, with a full bath for each, two living areas, and two amazing patio’s the space is wonderful for a family reunion like ours. The views from the upper level are amazing too.
Cell service is non-existent, so you will need to turn on your wi-fi calling. And the kitchen is a little tight for such a big space, but other than that it is all AMAZING.
4.9
We stayed at the home for my 50th birthday weekend. There were 12 adults and all couples had beautiful bedrooms with their own bathrooms. The veranda spaces provide breathtaking views and comfortable places to hang out.
The host, Elaine, helped us secure a private chef for a birthday dinner. It was so helpful to have a chef that knew the space and they provided an excellent experience and meal.
Our favorite was ending each evening on the 3rd floor great room for night caps and games.
This is a special property and the touches and details added to the excellent experience. I could not recommend this lovely home more.
Thank you Elaine and Heidi fir a 50th I will cherish.
4.9
Grand and sophisticated without being pretentious. The Stone House was a perfect location for our multi-generational family gathering. It can handle a crowd and provided everyone with generous private space. Comfortable dining for 14, two large covered porches (we loved these in all sorts of weather), a great yard, and gardens well suited for family photos. We could not have found a better place. 10 out of 10.
4.9
we got there with ease. we picked our rooms. we had nice spaghetti dinner on our first night. then we had breakfasts before we went to the reunion at marriott convention center. we had great tours in mystic and groton. the location is so great.
4.9
We loved the house, especially that each bedroom had its own bathroom and 3 bedrooms also had a gas fireplace. The top floor has a cozy entertaining room to watch movies and hang out. The grounds are beautiful and the history of the house is fascinating. I would highly recommend for family gatherings.
4.9
This house does not disappoint, it’s a great place for friends re-unions or family gatherings. Great location to the wineries in stonington, 5 minute drive to mystic, beautiful and serene
4.9
The house is well appointed and truly lovely. The background history adds to its charm. It’s rare for a house to be able satisfy the needs for so many. It is spacious inside and wonderful outside gatherings as well. We loved it.
4.9
We stayed here just this past weekend for a 50th birthday celebration for the group of us as well all just turned 50. We have known each other since college and wanted to celebrate together. This home is perfect for a group. Appointed with everything you could imagine, decorated beautifully, beautiful suites, veranda and 3rd floor gathering space. Close to everything, restaurants, the Mystic Seaport, activities, etc. I can not say enough about the ease of check-in and check-out and will definitely look to stay here again. Beautiful home and beautiful property!
4.9
We had our family reunion here and wanted a place where we could hang together (not just sleep). We weren't disappointed. There is the main living room, large dining table we could all sit at, and an upstairs movie/family area where the younger generation could hang. Each room had historical tidbits we'd discover and share. Outdoors is a huge field where we played sports together and enjoyed the large fire pit at night. The house is close to the beach and Mystic Seaport which we enjoyed but most valuable was the time we had just being together, cooking and eating, and lounging around. Thank you for a very meaningful stay!!
4.9
This was our group’s second stay at the Stone House, and we could not have asked for better accommodations. When another host canceled our booking on the morning of our arrival, we reached out to Elaine on a long shot since the house was listed as available. She quickly accommodated our request and literally saved our weekend. Simply put, the house is magnificent. On top of the huge lawn and beautiful exterior, it is abundantly clear the pride and passion with which Elaine and her family keep the interior of the house. There was more than enough room for our group to fit comfortably at night, the kitchen made preparing large meals a breeze, and we had plenty of indoor and outdoor space to hang out and eat. The close proximity to downtown Mystic as well as Rhode Island beaches solidifies this house as a fabulous rental property as well. Book it!
4.9
Weekend Getaway
Elaine was a great host and the property was beautiful! Highly recommend for a large group.
4.9
Magnificent Mansion!
More than enough room for our family, but cozy. Plenty of privacy and quiet on 2nd floor veranda for those who had to do some work. First floor veranda was absolutely perfect for dinners, especially with a 4 year old and almost 2 year old. Elaine suggested nearby McQuade’s Market for pick up catered meals (with plenty of choices and delicious). Also, Angies has fabulous pizzas! Little ones had plenty of running space and horseshoes, and for corn hole fun! Town is quaint and beautiful. Nearby winery enjoyed by some! Come and enjoy! Thank you for your hospitality, Elaine!
4.9
Perfect Property
Stayed at Elaine’s house for my wedding weekend and the home was perfect. Elaine was very welcoming and accommodating and the home was fully stocked with anything we could have needed. Friends and family had nothing but great things to say and everyone will be sure to stay at the Stone House their next time in town (if it isn’t already booked!)
4.9
House was absolutely gorgeous! It was so cool too see all the history all over the walls. Would recommend this house to anyone. House was so clean and the pictures online didn’t do it justice.
4.9
We were a group of 6 couples and the house was perfect ! Elaine was a lovely & gracious host. She has maintained the house wonderfully and it is furnished thoughtfully ! Loved even the outdoors, especially the rock. We would come back again. Thank you
4.9
Amazing place!
We were a group of 6 couples and the house was perfect ! Elaine was a lovely & gracious host. She has maintained the house wonderfully and it is furnished thoughtfully ! Loved even the outdoors, especially the rock. We would come back again. Thank you
4.9
Weekend getaway
House was absolutely gorgeous! It was so cool too see all the history all over the walls. Would recommend this house to anyone. House was so clean and the pictures online didn’t do it justice.
4.9
Had a fantastic weekend at the stone house. My brothers and some extended family stayed for a golf/casino trip. The home was lovely and the setting was picturesque. We spent most of the time outside on the covered porch to get relief from the uncharacteristically warm weather and the breeze and shade were welcomed. The great room on the third floor was perfect to watch a game together and socialize without being on top of one another. Bedrooms were spacious and en suite baths helped with our group size. Everyone had their own space throughout the property and there were lovely common areas to spend time with one another. 10/10 recommend. Thanks Elaine!
4.9
Great Family Rental!
Had a fantastic weekend at the stone house. My brothers and some extended family stayed for a golf/casino trip. The home was lovely and the setting was picturesque. We spent most of the time outside on the covered porch to get relief from the uncharacteristically warm weather and the breeze and shade were welcomed. The great room on the third floor was perfect to watch a game together and socialize without being on top of one another. Bedrooms were spacious and en suite baths helped with our group size. Everyone had their own space throughout the property and there were lovely common areas to spend time with one another. 10/10 recommend. Thanks Elaine!
4.9
We rented the stone house with our adult children , spouses and 2 grand babies for a short stay as we had a family wedding in the area. The house was immaculate, kitchen was fully stocked with plenty of plates, pots, pans , utensils and every possible cooking gadget imaginable. The bed linens were clean, soft and comfortable, bathrooms clean and gorgeous. Plenty of space to spread out. The owner had everything marked and labeled and your every possible need / question was taken care of. Very organized which we all loved and appreciated. The property was beautiful with plenty of parking. Great…. great location into Mystic, watch Hill, wineries etc. spectacular views as well. I say house but really it’s a beautiful mansion/castle a true labor of love as the house was restored to magnificent! The history of the house is fascinating the old family photos amazing.
This house, mansion, castle is a perfect home for family/friends gathering. Absolutely “Not a house to be abused, but a home to be appreciated and respected”. Our only regret was that we were so wrapped up in the family wedding itinerary/events that we didn’t have the time to truly appreciate this gem of a property. However , we hope to return and spend more time relaxing in this beautiful retreat of a home! Thank you Elaine
4.9
Gorgeous Home
We rented the stone house with our adult children , spouses and 2 grand babies for a short stay as we had a family wedding in the area. The house was immaculate, kitchen was fully stocked with plenty of plates, pots, pans , utensils and every possible cooking gadget imaginable. The bed linens were clean, soft and comfortable, bathrooms clean and gorgeous. Plenty of space to spread out. The owner had everything marked and labeled and your every possible need / question was taken care of. Very organized which we all loved and appreciated. The property was beautiful with plenty of parking. Great…. great location into Mystic, watch Hill, wineries etc. spectacular views as well. I say house but really it’s a beautiful mansion/castle a true labor of love as the house was restored to magnificent! The history of the house is fascinating the old family photos amazing.
This house, mansion, castle is a perfect home for family/friends gathering. Absolutely “Not a house to be abused, but a home to be appreciated and respected”. Our only regret was that we were so wrapped up in the family wedding itinerary/events that we didn’t have the time to truly appreciate this gem of a property. However , we hope to return and spend more time relaxing in this beautiful retreat of a home! Thank you Elaine
4.9
Amazing!
From the first communication to the last, it was quick and positive. Even when we didn’t communicate, they showed their thoughtfulness for the guest—for example, brought salt over on a potentially snowy/icy day. This was perfect for our retreat while attending a conference in Mystic! We each had our own room and bathroom while having a stunning gathering space just of our own—no hotel lobby or cramming into a hotel room. WiFi was spot on and amenities were plentiful. Thank you Elaine and Heidi!!
4.9
Exceeded our Expectations!
Just a fabulous weekend all around. Elaine and Heidi were incredible hosts, answering all of our questions promptly (Elaine even called restaurants to see who delivered and/or could take a party of our size) and Heidi greeted us and helped to get us acclimated. The house was spectacular; spotless, well appointed and beautiful views (we also loved the historical nature of the home). Cannot recommend this place enough for a family or friend getaway!
4.9
Long weekend at the Mansion
Beautiful and high quality home w tons of space for all. Good communication. A great place for special events for larger groups!
4.9
Beautiful. Quiet.
Lovely.
4.9
Beautiful. Quiet.
Lovely.
4.9
Could move in.
Beautiful. Quiet.
Lovely.
4.9
Easy to reach renter/ property manager. Multiple places to gather inside and out, but could have privacy when needed. Would stay again in a heartbeat and highly recommend to all.
4.9
We thoroughly enjoyed a long weekend at the house with family friends. Felt like our own private resort. Everyone loved having their own bathroom and bedroom and gathering on the large verandas. House is meticulously renovated and cared for. Elaine and the property manager, Holly, are friendly, courteous and easily accessible.
4.9
The place was immaculate and had everything out group of 10 needed for a wonderful stay.
Easy to reach renter/ property manager. Multiple places to gather inside and out, but could have privacy when needed. Would stay again in a heartbeat and highly recommend to all.
4.9
Spacious, lovely house in a charming town
We thoroughly enjoyed a long weekend at the house with family friends. Felt like our own private resort. Everyone loved having their own bathroom and bedroom and gathering on the large verandas. House is meticulously renovated and cared for. Elaine and the property manager, Holly, are friendly, courteous and easily accessible.
4.9
The house was even better than we had expected - it is gorgeous, historic and enormous but cozy, comfortable and has a friendly vibe. We were an extended family of ten with a toddler and an infant - the house worked so well. The grounds are beautiful, perfect for soft ball, soccer snd sitting in the sun. We had cocktails on the veranda and enjoyed the view of the Sound. We ate dinner on the patio one evening but the dining room was elegant and welcoming too. Kitchen super well stocked. Bedrooms are lovely. We really enjoyed the whole weekend. Stonington is beautiful too.
4.9
One of our best family gatherings ever
The house was even better than we had expected - it is gorgeous, historic and enormous but cozy, comfortable and has a friendly vibe. We were an extended family of ten with a toddler and an infant - the house worked so well. The grounds are beautiful, perfect for soft ball, soccer snd sitting in the sun. We had cocktails on the veranda and enjoyed the view of the Sound. We ate dinner on the patio one evening but the dining room was elegant and welcoming too. Kitchen super well stocked. Bedrooms are lovely. We really enjoyed the whole weekend. Stonington is beautiful too.
4.9
Excellent Property
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the Stone House while visiting CT for our son's graduation from the Coast Guard Academy. The Stone House was spacious and allowed all extended members of our family to have their privacy while still enjoying time with each other in the common areas and verandas. Stone House is an amazing property! The house was super clean and well appointed! Communicating with the owner and property manager was easy and they answered all our questions in a very timely manner. I highly recommend Stone House if you want a very special experience in a nice and quiet location with a gorgeous view!
4.9
Beautiful property!
Great experience. Everything was wonderful! Highly recommend
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Stonington?
The average price for a rental in Stonington is $511 per night. This rental is $1,478 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Iconic Mystic Mansion. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Iconic Mystic Mansion pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Iconic Mystic Mansion?
We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Stonington
Explore all rentals in StoningtonStonington travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun
Guides
Things to Do in Galveston, Texas
Guides
Top Things to Do in Myrtle Beach
Guides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023
Featured Rentals
Architectural Vacation Rentals: Experience the Beauty of Unique Properties
Featured Rentals
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Vacation Rentals Around the World