Great place

We loved our stay at the Tinmill Cottage. It was the center of everything we wanted to do. Had laundry onsite which was super helpful. Living room and kitchen were very spacious! We enjoyed hearing the train coming and going.

We absolutely loved this property for our 6 night stay. It was walking distance to Hill City restaurants and grocery store (if you chose), but on the "quiet" side of the hill. The quiet was only broken by the entertaining whistle of the 1880 tourist train every few hours between 9 and 5ish. The location was convenient to our hiking trailheads in Custer State Park and Black Hills National Forest. The cabin was perfect for the two of us, but could have been just as comfortable for family with children. We found the cabin to be immaculately clean with all the appliances up to date and in working order. The living room and kitchen was spacious with lots of natural light. There was a deck on three sides of the home with multiple seating areas, one under a small gazebo. The kitchen and bathroom was furnished with all the necessities needed for most occupants. We did have to provide some storage bags and spices, but all was good. The beds were comfortable, the handheld pulsating shower head was good and there was plenty of hot water. We appreciated having the covered carport to protect our vehicle from the elements and the willingness of the owner allowing us to hose the dirt from our car after driving on the gravel highway to Spearfish. We would strongly recommend this property for anyone looking to feel like they were getting away from it all while being in the middle of everything.

My husband and I had been planning our trip to South Dakota for 3 years and staying at Tin Mill Cottage was like finding a "nugget" of gold in Hill City. The cottage was clean and had every luxury of home. It was nice after a long day of sight seeing to come back to the comforts of Tin Mill. The location was absolutely perfect for our plans - close to Mt Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer Park and not far away from Rapid City. We had daily morning & sometimes afternoon visits from wild turkey & deer in the yard. We had a wonderful vacation! I would like to add a couple of things about comments I read previous to booking Tin Mill Cottage...there was a complaint about 2 hotels nearby and the train being so close. The hotels were there but did not create any noise and we were still on a hill with our own privacy. Yes, the train ran by a couple of times a day while we were there but never early in the morning or late at night. If we go back to South Dakota, and we would really love to..we will most definitely stay at Tin Mill Cottage.

Excellent location! It was so nice to be able to come “home” after a busy day exploring!! Location was close to the road but with the trees in the back of the home, we were tucked into the woods! Excellent communication throughout our stay as well. A+++

We had a great time the house fit all our needs and was very clean. The location was perfect, close to everying and the view was great for gawking !

This was a wonderful place to stay during the Sturgis motorcycle rally. Great location And wonderful hosts.

We loved our stay at the Tin Mill Cottage! It's the perfect location above Hill City so you're close to all the tourist attractions! We packed our days full of activities and it was nice having a home to come back to and relax before starting again the next day! The owners were very responsive and messaged just to make sure everything was going well! It has became one of our favorite VRBO's and would be the first one we would look for on future visits and recommend to friends and family! Thanks again!

Comfortable home setting. Clean and well furnished. Wi-Fi and cable TV. Hill City is in the middle of the Black Hills so excellent location.

This cute little house was perfect for 4 of us. 2 rooms and 1 bathroom. We didn't use the kitchen to cook but it appeared to be fully stocked should you need it. We rode the 1880 Train and walked to the station from the house. We could of walked to the main street with the shops and restaurants also but it rained most days… we didn't let that spoil out trip though. Hill City properties were very nice and attentive even sending me a text letting me know that severe weather was in the forecast. We appreciated this! And luckily we didnt get anything other than a thunderstorm. The house close to Mt Rushmore and Crazy Horse we even made our way to Deadwood and Belle Fourche. Beautiful drives and cute mountain towns.

Very nice place to stay. Very clean and well kept. Everything was labeled great. Communication was great.

lovely place great location. the boys enjoyed playing in he yard and watching the train go by.

Great home away from home. Very clean and lots of room. Location was perfect to visit Mount Rushmore and Badlands. Cute town with lots of shops.

We had a wonderful stay. The cabin exceeded our expectations. We cooked on the grill, our backyard was a forest, and we overlooked the town. It was so peaceful and beautiful, we highly recommend this retreat.

This is a great place in a great location. Very clean. We would definitely stay there again.

Neat, clean, and well-maintained. Thank you!

We were very satisfied with the property. It was a very nice place to stay.

We came out to visit our daughter and this was the perfect spot. Quiet, yet close to all the attractions. We saw deer in the back yard every morning. Would highly recommend!

The cabin was as described. Very clean and neat. Location was great. Close enough to walk to downtown Hill City yet not in the craziness of it all. The hostess was great and check in was a breeze! We would defiantly stay again.

We loved our family vacation at the Tin Mill Cottage. It was centrally located for all the Black Hills sites. The cottage was spacious and had everything we could want. The deck was a great place to have our morning coffee and watch the deer play. We would definitely stay here again.

The cabin was clean and good sized. The location in Hill City was perfectly placed to see all the attractions in the area. The Bennington were kind and easy to deal with. We would definitely stay here again.

Very good. But the house had that old musty smell when we walked in.

Location, location, location set between Mount Rushmore ,Crazy Horse and Custer State Park in quaint little Hill City over looking the Steam Railroad., makes this place ideal for exploring the area. The cabin suited our needs 2 adults and a teenager. We saw white tailed deer one evening while drinking on the deck and one morning had wild turkeys on the lawn. A couple of suggestions I would make is the outdoor light for the BBQ needs to be relocated as once dark you cannot see a thing and maybe some brighter bulbs in the bathroom . I would fully recommend this property.

Had a great stay. Centrally located for the best attractions.

Great Stay. Quiet little corner with great access to all area sites. Seeing the steam train go by just below the cottage is a great extra. Would stay here again.

This was the perfect place for our family when visiting the Black Hills. It was centrally located and allowed us to visit all the nearby attractions we wanted to see including Badlands and Wind Cave National Parks, Custer State Park, Crazy Horse, Mount Rushmore, Devil’s Tower, Spearfish Canyon, Needles Highway and Deadwood. The cabin is on top of a small hill which allowed us to overlook part of the city, along with the beautiful mountains surrounding Hill City. We also had deer we could watch in the yard on several locations, which was exciting for our kids. The owners also went above and beyond our expectations. Our family left ear buds in the cabin when we left. The owners were able to mail these to us which we greatly appreciated. Overall, we couldn’t have been happier with the our stay at this property or the service we received before, during, and after our stay!

Very nice property. It was perfect for the 4 adults. Location was perfect for the area.

Loved the house. Great location and very affordable. Owner was super friendly and nice.

very nice property and easy to get to and great location

We had a great time on our vacation to the Black Hills area. The Tin Mill Cottage was the perfect home base. We enjoyed cooking dinners on the grill on the deck.

Dated, by very nice place! Clean, cute, and convenient! Plenty of room for our crewcab pickup with a 16’ trailer to park! Highly recommended by all 4 of us that stayed! Kinda cool watching the 1880 train come through just down the hill. Deer everywhere also.

We enjoyed our stay very much. The house is as advertised and right in the middle of Hill City. The house was clean and comfortable.