We really liked this house! I brought my nephews here to celebrate the youngest's graduation from high school. They had a blast! We actually didn't end up spending a ton of time at the property, but it is in a good location and had everything we needed. Communication with the owner was good. I would like to come here again and spend more time at the house.

This was our second stay at this beautiful haven on San Juan Island. Last year, we fell in love with the island and this place, in particular. This year only reinforced how much we love island living, but also the experience of being in this peaceful setting. The house is the perfect blend of modern amenities and warm, rustic design and feel. The surrounding acreage is a lovely playground for pups/people. Its location is convenient to pretty much the entire island, being less than 10 minutes from Friday Harbor restaurants and ferry, and little more than that to parks both south and north, as well as Roche Harbor. The filtered views of the Olympic mountains and the Haro Strait are a bonus. Hopefully we can come back and stay again.

We had such a wonderful stay that we didn’t want to leave! The house is so warm and inviting, with all the touches of home and everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The property is wonderful to walk and explore as well, especially if you have a pup with you like we did. Can’t wait to stay here again!

What a gem! The property is just wonderful. My dog was in heaven-free to run and chase balls. The house is a little quirky which is (mostly) charming. I had to laugh tho. Caroline must have been tall! I am not. In the mirror, I saw the top of my head. TV is kind of non existant. I remember that TV from the 90's. Couldn't work it. But, good WIFI to stream on laptop and work. It went out of few times, but not for long. Really nice young couple rented the smaller cottage next door, so I can't comment on the spa or fire pit as it wasn't available to us. The house is very cozy. I read in the reading nook and on the porch. This house is for readers. But please, replace the couch! Can't wait to go back and stay longer.

The cabin was perfect for our group of four, and our dog really enjoyed playing catch on the 5 acres of property surrounding.

This eclectic cabin was the perfect touch to our weekend getaway that we booked kind of last minute to celebrate 4 milestone birthdays with friends! Communication with Blythe was easy and helpful. We even ordered a Hello Fresh box of meals to be delivered to the front door on our first day, which arrived seamlessly. The kitchen had everything that we could ever need in terms of preparing meals - although it did take a bit to find things in all of the drawers and cupboards. :) Labels would be a nice touch, but not necessary. The location worked out well to drive to any spot on the island pretty easily - we also brought electric bikes and one wheels, and could easily charge them on the deck and take them out to various excursions. Loved the hammock swing on the porch! Having the cabin booked the same time as the studio next door - we didn't have any issues with the other renters (we barely saw them), but we would have loved to have use of the hot tub! It would have just been an extra perk at the end of long days of exploring. We knew that wasn't part of our rental, though. Having the option of a fire pit would be lovely, too. Loved all of the board games, books, and cozy nooks. The bed downstairs was comfortable, but it had squeaky springs, and was loud on the tile floors because it moved easily when you sat on it, or rolled over in bed (not something we're used to). Our friends said the bed upstairs seemed to have a bit hump in it, but they slept decently. We would recommend future renters bring slippers or cozy socks to wear around the house - especially on the cooler tile floors, since the house is shoe free. It would be more comfortable to have a window covering on the bathtub window and small bathroom window by the front door - especially for ladies using the shower, but not a deal breaker. We were grateful to have a welcoming spot to come home to after each of our adventures, and none of us wanted to leave! Thank you for sharing your family home with us.

The house is a very comfortably constructed and furnished. The kitchen is very well equipped. It is a little difficult to locate which drawers contain what utensils, napkins, placemats, etc., but this is a very minor problem. The upstairs has a couple of quirks. The wonderful bathtub has no curtains and looks out on the neighbor's deck (granted some distance away). A little more privacy would be nice. There are many sweet touches to this obviously beloved house. And it was wonderful that our (adult) kids could bring their dogs!

very cozy home. beautiful property.

Had a great stay at the rustic farmhouse even though we were not there very much. It was perfect, quiet and comfy.

Suited our needs perfectly. Loved all the books and the sharing of a beloved family recipe for Rhubarb pie.

It’s a bit hard to put into words how much we enjoyed this place, how calming the land was, how you could feel the warmth of the home from the moment we walked in. But after looking at the photo album that documents how it was built; how much sweat, and probably just a bit of blood and tears as well, but above all, how much love went into building it for the owner’s family, it’s easy to understand why we felt that way. It’s a special home, on a special island. We can’t wait to go back.

This property is so quaint and restful! Loved every minute of it!

A special retreat with huge oak trees on about 5 acres. There was big storm when we were there. You could step outside to feel the wind and go back in the cozy house to get warm. Our dog loved it too. This was our third time there. And we will be back.

Everything about the stay was exactly as described. Communication was quick and helpful. The location was perfect for me, my mom and our dogs. We had everything we needed and we will be renting again. Five stars all the way.

Such a beautiful, restful and magical place. Thank you so much!

We loved the house . Lovely grounds to walk around . Was homey and comfortable . Kitchen was well equipped and living room comfortable . Was nicer than the pictures suggest . So cozy.

What an amazing and beautiful property this is!!!! From the moment we stepped in we felt right at home and we were so comfortable as were our dogs. This house has everything you could possibly ever need from a great kitchen, comfortable beds, washer and dryer, a claw foot tub, spectacular grounds, amazing flowers, a hammock chair, great privacy, so quiet and stars at night that are unparalleled!!!! All this and only 3.3 miles to Lime Kiln Point for whale watching and a 9 minute drive to Friday Harbor for all the great restaurants and shops. We already want to come back and stay here again!!! It was perfect for us and our dogs and Blythe was such a great hostess and easy to contact! Stay here you won’t be sorry…. it was truly truly MAGICAL!!!

We had a wonderful time at this property. It is a beautiful house with a lot of charm. The home is filled with art and has beautiful architecture. The view from the house is amazing. We will come back again next year or sooner if we can.

Perfect, peaceful, great art, books and music. Can't wait to return!

A great retreat location and house for a quiet, simple existence vacation.

Our family has gathered on SJI for many years and the Rhubarb House is our favorite property. We will reschedule our stay for its availability. The grounds are magnificent and the property a "home" which is always welcoming. This stay we saw deer, of course, but also quail, a great horned owl and an actual blue bird. This is a true island gem!Brian and Mary McDonald

Our family has gathered on SJI for many years and the Rhubarb House is our favorite property. We will reschedule our stay for its availability. The grounds are magnificent and the property a "home" which is always welcoming. This stay we saw deer, of course, but also quail, a great horned owl and an actual blue bird. This is a true island gem! Brian and Mary McDonald

Enjoyed the intimate, cozy, slightly quirky main cottage which was like staying at a family home. Plenty of birds, deer passing through, and frogs croaking at night! The location is an ideal distance between Lime Kiln Park and Friday Harbor.

It is obvious the amount of care and thought that went in to creating this magical spot to relax and unwind. The property is amazingly beautiful and quiet.

This house was so perfect for our stay. It has so much character and warmth. It also had everything you could think to need from an extensive kitchen and spices to a hot tub , rolling hills, tree swing, and gorgeous sunrises We made wonderful family memories here for a lifetime! Thank you so much again!

This house feels like it was plucked out of the English country side - a lovely, quaint cottage set amidst beautiful trees and rolling hills - a tiny slice of heaven. If you are looking for all the bells and whistles (like a big TV and modern appliances) - this is not your place. But if you are looking for something unique, slightly rustic and well-loved - then I would suggest checking this place out. I wish we could buy it and call it our own. From the gently used furniture, to the amazing and awe inspiring book collection, to the eclectic CD collection, to the comfy reading nook right out of a magazine, we could not get enough of this place! Even though it was cold we loved being outside in the back of the house where our dog romped freely and safely and we walked among beautiful old trees and took in the night sky (stars!!). At night we read in the quiet with no temptations of screens and for the first time in long while we finally felt relaxed! We are already planning our next escape to this house when time allows. It's the kind of place you can go back to time and time again and know that each time you will make many more happy memories. Thanks for the great experience!

Even over a rainy weekend we found ourselves enchanted in the home and on the property. Thank you!

Secluded and beautiful with all the comforts of home. We love it.

This place is a soul and character filled getaway... we loved it, there is not another spot like it on the planet... if you want a boring cookie-cutter place...this is not for you, but if you love a place with an amazing book-nook next to the stairs to spend endless ours reading... you will love it! The property is mazing too... perched on exposed bedrock and surrounded by San Juan Island Prairie and oaks!

A wonderful place to hang out, even on a rainy weekend.

We had a fabulous stay! The house is quite cozy and comfortable with views of the mountains and ocean. It's a beautiful, quiet property with lovely walks and we had visits from a family of deer each evening! We would definitely like to stay here on our next visit!

quaint and picturesque - would definitely recommend