We booked this house for our family of 4 (two kids ages 10 & 13), and it was the perfect fit for us! Both bedrooms are on the lower level and connected by a covered deck. One of the bedrooms has 2 beds, so my daughter and son were able to spread out and have their own space. The bedrooms and living area are air conditioned, which is a huge plus. The kitchen is open air, but we enjoyed our time in the mornings listening to the ocean waves and island rain roll in while having coffee. The outdoor shower has the BEST views and the entire house is completely private. The pool is small, but my kids still thoroughly enjoyed it and had zero complaints. The kitchen has high end appliances and all the necessary amenities to cook a meal. The living room has plenty of seating and a smart tv, so we enjoyed wrapping up our day there in the air conditioning. There was plenty of beach towels, bath towels, and a washer/dryer. The host was amazing to communicate with. Overall, this is one of the best houses we’ve stayed at on St. John, located in a peaceful bay, and has amazing views from every room. We will definitely be back!

This spot is perfect if you want to be out of town and away from the crowd. The view is amazing. Our 3 girls were comfy together in the guest room. The home owner and local manager were very accommodating and helpful. We would stay here again.

Check-in was simple as we were met by the caretaker who walked us through the property. The owners notes about the islands was incredibly helpful. The house was a great mix of air conditioned locations and open Caribbean style spaces. The view is spectacular, and you can see St. Croix on most days. The kitchen was well equipped and the layout was great for cooking. Internet was reliable and allowed us to work remotely for a couple days. Having the solar and battery backups was critical, as the power on the island is not reliable. I highly recommend this property, and I am planning a return trip in the near future.

We absolutely loved staying at unicorn by the sea. Its views were amazing and the house had absolutely anything and everything we could need for our stay. Very well appointed it was clean and well designed/decorated. We will definitely be back. This place is a total find!

Unicorn by the Sea was absolute perfection, and I don't know how we'd stay somewhere else whenever we get the chance to return to St. John! I really appreciated all of John's help with recommendations pre- and during the trip, and while we never really needed anything from the property manager while we were there, communication with her was easy and responsive. The home is gorgeous and really well laid out; we especially loved having both open air dining and an A/C enclosed area for hanging out. The pool was the perfect size for our family (two kids, 6 & 9). The kitchen was well-stocked, and grocery delivery made it easy to eat at home a few nights when we didn't feel like driving on the adventurous roads after a day on the beach. Furniture/beds were comfy, too. The only downside was that eventually we had to leave and return to work/school :)

Views are stunning, private pool is a happy retreat at the end of a long day of exploring! Quiet and private neighborhood. Town is 15/20min drive with easy access to grocery store as it’s on your way (starfish or dolphin). The first drive out was an adventure but after that, old hat. Took a couple charters with Cruz Bay Watersports which you catch at the dock of the Westin which is also on the way out to Unicorn. Well appointed kitchen which allowed us to dine at home with our family some of the nights. Unicorn is truly a unicorn, thank you for sharing it with us!

We stayed at Unicorn with our 4 kids in March 2024. The views from the balcony were spectacular. We were mesmerized by the colors of the sunsets and the water. The bedrooms were nice but a little tight having 3 teens with us. We loved the outdoor shower, the dipping pool, the outdoor night lighting, grill, washer/dryer, well stocked kitchen, and ability to communicate with our host with ease. The location is great overlooking Fish Bay and just under 15 min from Cruz Bay. Overall the views from the open air kitchen and dining space made this home for us truly special and something our family will think back on with delight and hopes for a return amidst the forever memories we will always carry with us...

Loved everything about this house! Beautiful view, well stocked, had everything we needed and more. Owner & Manager were very responsive to any questions. Definitely recommend Unicorn by the Sea!