Beautiful! Lots of amenities.

We love the Pridwin! One caveat - the coffee is excellent, but, frankly, the Pridwin is quite upscale (read pricey). Free cofffee would be a lovely, graceful addition to an otherwise magnificent experience.

It was a fantastic time and room. Gorgeous hotel. Felt like I didn't need to leave.

The hotel and the grounds are gorgeous. There are so many lovely places to sit and admire the views. All staff were amazing. All were cordial, prompt and attentive. From check-in to bell men to pool staff to dock boys, bartenders, housekeeping, waitresses and all staff were fantastic. Whoever does the hiring for this hotel should be commended! We would love to return.

This hotel has unethically taken money from me. An authorized reservation was made and I reported it to the hotel and expedia. I got a message saying " The Pridwin Hotel cannot honor your upcoming booking on 6/28/2024 " yet they refused to refund the unauthorized purchase and I have had to take the matter up with my bank as well as the consumer protection bureau. This hotel is a total joke please avoid these theives.

If you are on the fence about The Pridwin or even Shelter Island I hope this reviews tips you to book. My family and I had a fantastic stay. The property is amazing, Shelter Island is great, the amenities are top notch and the overall setting is spectacular but what made it truly special is the service. They could not have been kinder to my daughter and us. They have really outdone on making you feel welcome.

Excellent Service

Everything was exquisite!

Very elegant

What a beautiful property!! Recently renovated and sparkling in every area. Gorgeous light filled corner room facing the Bay. Dining on porch with lovely view and very good food. Lovely staff, though front desk seemed new and not aware of what activities were available, though listed on the welcome letter. Small frustration that the spa was closed as the only masseuse was sick for the whole week. But, hotel's private boat took us for lunch at Sag Harbour, at no charge!? Wonderful and can't wait to return!

easy access to forest hiking trail and Cackels reserve and beach made easier with the complimentary bikes;pool and sauna were great ways to download after

It is a beautiful site with excellent service. It is expensive.

Recently renovated. Keeps vintage decor around. The concierge promptly addresses customer questions via email. Very relaxing outdoor terraces. Food in general can be improved. Katherine, Loren, and David were amazing. Big shout out. I'm sure I left someone out. Staff is awesome.

Exceeded expectations

A fantastic getaway In Shelter island. It was a five star experience.

Beautiful resort with historic charm, very well positioned on a scenic cove. Upgraded luxury with a classic yacht club tone that is both beautiful and comfortable yet approachable and relaxing. Service is excellent and there to support your needs everyone is attentive. Plenty of amenities to enjoy but all set to a relaxing tone.

Newly renovated, 1st class bedding, bathroom, Nespresso machine,. Beautiful pool. Great service, nice landscaping.

Property is extremely well maintained, great location and the staff was excellent. GM- Jack makes sure that you are having a great time and have whatever you want or need.

The hotel and grounds have/are being redone in a good, but not too much, way. We are off-season visitors, so we got to see all the effort they are putting in to make the place great. Wonderful setting. Wide range of activities to choose from. Staff, very helpful and competent. We recommend The Pridwin.

Wonderful place, great views of the water! Would absolutely stay here again.

wonderful

Great location. Hotel is old and needs updating. No elevator.

The bathrooms in the guest rooms need to be updated. Everything else was just fine

The hotel was built in 1927. The room felt like It had the original mattress. So uncomfortable. Minimal amenities. Room was tiny and dark with one outlet

Nice location. Old school hotel. Charming. The rooms are small.

Did not have any type of facilities for ADA, not wheelchair assessable. no elevator to 2, 3 floor. need reservations for dinner which we asked and they gave us a menu but did not inform us that reservations were required, did not have a good attitude toward the handicap treated us as if we were intruding gave us a feeling we shouldn't be there. Did have 2 aADA parking spots the rest of parking was on top of hill and not wheelchair friendly.

Did not have any type of facilities for ADA, not wheelchair assessable. no elevator to 2, 3 floor. need reservations for dinner which we asked and they gave us a menu but did not inform us that reservations were required, did not have a good attitude toward the handicap treated us as if we were intruding gave us a feeling we shouldnt be there. Did have 2 aADA parking spots the rest of parking was on top of hill and not wheelchair friendly.

The weather didnt cooperate but the ambience of the hotel was nice. That being said, Shelter Island after Labor Day is very quiet.

The weather didn't cooperate but the ambience of the hotel was nice. That being said, Shelter Island after Labor Day is very quiet.

Beautiful location! Amazing pool. Sweet, friendly, young staff. Good food.Bathroom is little old fashioned, but the bed is super comfy.

Beautiful location! Amazing pool. Sweet, friendly, young staff. Good food. Bathroom is little old fashioned, but the bed is super comfy.

The location is everything. Beautiful water views from the lobby & restaurant. Beach is very small but nice for people with kids. Pool is lovely. Good breakfast included, dining staff was very accommodating. Room was very clean, and charming, although a little tired, There are amenities, but it was like pulling teeth to find out what they are. Reception was staffed by college kids who only answered questions after finding someone else to ask, as if every day was their first day (what time is breakfast? what about using the bikes/water equipment? do you have board games?