Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!!

10.0

Outstanding(107 Reviews)

Cottage in Chincoteague Island, VA

4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind

High-end valuePrice for this property is higher than average in the area

About this cottage rental

Every room of this island cottage has been updated and furnished with fresh fixtures, furniture and decor in a relaxed, comfy coastal style.

Clean and well appointed, from the granite counter tops and stainless appliances in the kitchen to the new queen and twin sets in the charming bedrooms. Every detail of this island home was carefully considered to ensure your visit is relaxing and comfortable.

The wide and inviting front porch is the first thing you will notice as we welcome you to our island haven. Beyond the front door, you will find an open living room and kitchen designed for easy entertaining with plenty of seating and views through to the spacious screened porch. Eat in the kitchen or gather around the dining area on the screened porch.

Nestled in the back are two bedrooms; one with a queen and another with two twin beds. Both bedrooms feature smart flat screen TV's. All quality linens and hotel style towels are provided.

The tiled bathroom includes a roomy waterfall shower, as well as, a full sized washer and dryer.

In addition, this “Tesla friendly” coastal retreat has a conveniently located 240v EV recharge station, central air, wireless internet and smart TV's in the living room and both bedrooms.

Tucked away in the closest neighborhood to the Assateague National Seashore, this quiet street is only a few minutes to the beach, bike rentals, restaurants and shopping. Rental includes access to the community boat launch.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Family friendly

Map of Chincoteague Island, VA

Nearby attractions

Ocean City Boardwalk

51.6 mi

Salisbury Zoological Park

52.4 mi

Perdue Stadium

51.9 mi

Trimper Rides of Ocean City

50.2 mi

$$$$

Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!!

$$$$

10.0

Outstanding(107 Reviews)

Cottage in Chincoteague Island, VA

4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind

High-end valuePrice for this property is higher than average in the area

About this cottage rental

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Family friendly

Map of Chincoteague Island, VA

Nearby attractions

Ocean City Boardwalk

51.6 mi

Salisbury Zoological Park

52.4 mi

Perdue Stadium

51.9 mi

Trimper Rides of Ocean City

50.2 mi

Reviews

10.0

Outstanding(107 Reviews)

10.0

Sep 2024

The Starfish is a gem. Fantastic owners as well. Take good care of this property and it will take good care of you !

10.0

Aug 2024

This was our fourth time staying at the Starfish House- which just proves what a gem it is! It’s always spotless, comfortable, and communication is amazing. We will be back!

10.0

Aug 2024

Everything was fantastic. The house is beautifully maintained and tastefully decorated. Stocked with nice cookware and everything you need to get your vacation started right. Great location away from the main road, but everything you need is still close. Easy drive in the park to get to the beach and all the sights. Great communication with the hosts for anything we needed. Would recommend this home to anyone without hesitation.

10.0

Jul 2024

We really enjoyed our stay in this lovely house. Great location, really close to biking trail and Assateague! Definitely recommend! Communication was great!

10.0

Jul 2024

My family and I really enjoyed staying here. It was beautiful and clean. The hosts were also great communicators. I have used VRBO to rent many times at different price points. This place is in my top three. I would definitely return for a longer stay. Thank you!

10.0

Jul 2024

Wonderful stay at the Starfish Cottage. Felt like Home! Close the beach, clean and decorated so tastefully . We especially loved the screen porch for game nights.

10.0

Jul 2024

We loved this house in Chincoteague! The rooms were perfect for our family of 4 and the screened porch was a great place to hang out bug-free at night. The quiet streets were safe for the kids to bike on and the large yard and yard games (corn hole, ladder golf) were fun for everyone. Would love to come back!

10.0

Jul 2024

This was one of those properties that lives up to the pictures and description. The house is lovely, clean and cozy and located on a nice quiet street in Chincoteague Island. It's definitely worth the stay for your family.

10.0

Jun 2024

Cute cottage, great spaces and a wonderful kitchen. Great spot with amazing little details and calming color scheme - relax and read a book or watch a show, sit on the front swing and listen to the birds. Lots of option - plan to come back soon.

10.0

Jun 2024

This house is the essence of well-executed simple design, inside and out! From location, architecture, landscaping and interior design, to amenities, necessities and owner support, the Starfish House was a delightful vacation home for us to enjoy charming Chincoteague and Assateague.

10.0

Jun 2024

We had an amazing week in Chincoteague staying at The Starfish! The house was the perfect size for the four of us. Everything was clean and the host provided a few extras - Bluetooth speaker, boogie boards, and lots of board games. Will definitely stay at the Starfish when we return to Chincoteague!

10.0

Jun 2024

A wonderful place in an ideal location—even better than advertised. This delightful cottage has been thoroughly modernized and tastefully decorated. The porches are broad and cool even in the heat of the day, and the kitchen beautifully designed and equipped. Whether you’re pony-watching, beach-going, wilderness hiking or just getting away from it all, this is the perfect place to stay. We especially appreciated the host’s flexibility in modifying our initial reservation.

10.0

Apr 2024

Was welcoming from the time you drove up. This place was very clean, very well thought out, and we highly recommend. If you are wanting a clean spot, time to relax, and a place to make memories this is the one for you!

10.0

Apr 2024

This was a wonderful getaway retreat. You CANNOT TOP this little cottage. Everything is provided that you need: super clean, well decorated, and appointed and close to great restaurants and the quaint downtown area. We thoroughly enjoyed our time there. The communication with Jennifer (owner) could not have been better from the trip planning stage through the conclusion of our stay. She was immensely friendly and helpful. Stay at Starfish - you will not regret it.

10.0

Apr 2024

Absolutely lovely home, very clean and cozy! Great communication with hosts. Would definitely stay again when we go back to the Eastern Shore.

10.0

Apr 2024

We really enjoyed our stay at the Starfish. The house was newly renovated and had all the best amenities. The beds were very comfortables and we loved the big wrap around porch as well as the side screened porch. We would definitely stay here again!

10.0

Apr 2024

We love staying at the Starfish House! This was our third time and we’ve already booked another trip for August. Thanks for another cozy stay!

10.0

Apr 2024

This is absolute beach perfection! Beautifully decorated with upscale finishes and style, well appointed kitchen and bath, comfy beds, huge porch, so cute! we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Loved the quiet neighborhood and convenient location, very clean and comfortable, so easy to wish it was permanently our own. Many thanks for sharing your slice of Chincoteague heaven ☀️😘

10.0

Feb 2024

The house was very clean and nicely decorated-it had everything we needed. The owners even gave me a nice Birthday surprise-so thoughtful! Close to everything, quiet and safe neighborhood. Did not want to leave. We will stay here again!

10.0

Oct 2023

My adult daughter and I booked the Starfish House for a weekend of biking and getting together w other family members who stayed in close proximity to the house. We were thrilled to enter a beautifully decorated, clean, renovated cottage with a beautiful sitting porch (some of it screened) to shield us from the mosquitoes that are so popular on Chincoteague Island! We enjoyed the welcome basket and bottle of wine-and that all supplies necessary were readily available ( t.p., paper towels, dish soap, laundry detergent, etc…) Access into the house was easy, and the ev charger and washer and driver also made life easier for the weekend. The only problem we encountered was that the oven was extremely difficult to use-wish there were directions… but luckily, our short stay didn’t require cooking. Had we needed to cook, the kitchen so beautifully renovated, would have not been so convenient to use without contracting the owner for instructions. Perhaps leaving directions in the welcome basket would have been a good idea. The inability to simply boil water for a cup of tea turned out to be quite frustrating. All in all, we had a lovely weekend and appreciated the comfortable beds, and extremely clean house. We would return to this house again for sure! Vanessa from NJ

10.0

Oct 2023

This cottage was very thoughtfully and tastefully remodeled and decorated, and was equally pleasing to the adults and the kids in our family. Location cannot be beat if you are looking to explore Assateague/Chincoteague. Hosts were very responsive and incredibly understanding. A clear winner.

10.0

Sep 2023

Nice quiet neighborhood, house was spotless and well-outfitted. The porch was delightful. Walking distance to stores, restaurants, activities. Would definitely stay here again.

10.0

Sep 2023

It was the perfect size house for just the two of us. It was newly renovated and very clean. The kitchen was really great with new higher end appliances. The neighborhood was quiet with easy access to the wildlife refuge and a bike rental company. Couldn’t have asked for a better stay.

10.0

Aug 2023

We loved staying at the Starfish House! This is our second trip and both times I have left saying that next time we'll stay longer! It's sparkling clean and fresh, well maintained, and stocked with everything you need!

10.0

Aug 2023

Exactly as advertised. Cozy, newly remodeled home in prime location. Extremely clean, well decorated, and high-end. Perfect for a couple or small family trip. Hosts were great to work with.

10.0

Jul 2023

Wow! The Starfish was amazing the second time around. My son, nephew and sister and I had the best week. There were sad faces when it was time to leave, but we're excited to plan our next visit. The Starfish was clean, cozy and had all of the amenities we needed. It was a hot one during in our stay, but the house was cool. The porch was wonderful to enjoy for breakfast and during some of the afternoon rain storms. The kids loved playing with their Hot Wheels and Bubbles on the awesome wrap around deck / porch. The area offers so many unique and wonderful adventures. We spent time at the beach, Tom's Cove, the Daisey Island Cruise, the Blueberry Festival, Island Creamery, shopping and so much more. Thanks to Jen and Brad for removing any stress about accommodations. We truly look forward to the next visit. Cheers! Melanie

10.0

Jul 2023

In a nut shell we loved the property, will definitely stay there again. Great property and owners!

10.0

Jul 2023

A lovely escape!! Quiet in early morning for coffee and journaling. Just a walk to delicious donuts at Sandy Pony. Very grateful for Weber BBQ. Amazing escape from 9th floor Philly condo.

10.0

Jun 2023

The house was very well decorated, super clean, and the location was very convenient (everything was a short drive or bike ride away)! Isn’t a huge place but had lots of space for everyone to spread out and was laid out well (the large wrap-around porch was great and was partially screened in). We rented bikes for the weekend from the Chincoteague Bike Shop (if you rent for more than 2 days they will deliver and pick-up which was a huge convenience). Overall-very nice place to stay!

10.0

May 2023

The interior was clean and had a classy maritime flair to it. It came with all amenities including a washer and dryer, a bathroom w/ rain shower, and a very well equipped kitchen, as well as a Weber barbecue on the veranda. The veranda goes around the house on three sides with a dinner table, a garden couch combo and several more seating areas including on romantic Holywood swing. The former two are shielded from the mosquitoes from the marshes by framed nets all around. The little settlement on Chincoteague has quite some small stores for most holiday needs close by. Many are walkable or can be reached from the Starfish within minutes by car or bike. Assateague National park is shy of a 10min drive or 30min walk away providing ample opportunity for fishing or crabbing in the marshes, swimming in the Atlantic, or walking through the forrests or swamps. The owners quickly responded to any questions and the communication was pleasant. Overall, we had a nice weekend on Chincoteague in the Starfish cottage.

10.0

Apr 2023

The cottage is completely updated and decorated beautifully and as pictured. The kitchen is well appointed with thought put into to every detail of what you will need for your stay. The neighborhood was quiet and peaceful and being less than two miles away from the state park, with nice trails and beautiful beaches made it a perfect getaway.

10.0

Apr 2023

What a wonderful weekend away! Celebrated our anniversary, Easter and time away as a family from the daily grind. Have always loved Chincoteague but finding this gem was a game changer. Jen was amazing to work with up to our stay and even checking in during our visit. Our little guy said it was the "most special ever beach house". The location, cleanliness and amenities were excellent. Everything you could need (except for more luggage to stay longer!) The Hosts thought of everything. Truly a wonderful time. Melanie

10.0

Oct 2022

A beautiful home with modern, upgraded amenities. Fantastic neighborhood and more than gracious hosts. You would love this property. A very special place with very special owners.

10.0

Sep 2022

The Starfish House is such a gem! We are so happy we found it for our getaway to Chincoteague. We went to visit Chincoteague and Assateague to vacation, go to the beach, and learn more about Misty of Chincoteague after reading the book. Jennifer was so helpful prior to our trip as we planned our itinerary of things to do and she even gave advice/answered questions promptly during our stay. The house is so well maintained and has so many wonderful details- a cozy screened in porch with hanging lights, a wrap around front porch with a whale picnic table that the kids loved eating breakfast and playing at, a porch swing, a beautiful/modern kitchen and the house is well furnished with decor that looks like it’s right out of a magazine. We loved the starfish themed decorations throughout the house. The bathroom shower is roomy and worked really well when helping our little ones bathe after the beach. The waterfall shower head is wonderful too. The location of the house is close to everything and made getting to the beach and lighthouse easy. We also enjoyed some tours with the Step Through Time tour of Main Street and Beebe Ranch, as well as the Assateague Explorer boat tour where we saw dolphins, and the Museum of Chincoteague was a great one for the kids. We finished the trip off with a visit to the delicious Island Creamery and even were delighted to see some of the wild ponies on the way to the beach. A fantastic VRBO and we hope to visit again in the future! Thank you, Jennifer and Brad!

10.0

Sep 2022

Really enjoyed my stay in this cute and well appointed clean cottage

10.0

Sep 2022

This was our second stay at The Starfish House and it looks as fresh and new as it did a year ago when we first visited. The owners are incredibly kind and showed up within minutes on a Saturday evening when we encountered an unexpected issue, which they were prepared and able to fix themselves -- eagerly and with a smile! Don't hesitate to book The Starfish. It's the best!

10.0

Aug 2022

The property was in a beautiful, quiet and charming neighborhood. It was easy to bike to the beach. The house is well equipped and comfortable.

10.0

Aug 2022

We had a wonderful time at the Starfish House. It’s a beautiful place to stay. So cozy, yet modern with lots of creative touches. Definitely planning on returning next summer!

10.0

Aug 2022

The house is beautifully decorated and very clean!! The hosts have thought of everything. Highly recommend!

10.0

Aug 2022

This was the perfect house for my husband, daughter, and me to experience the area. It's beautifully decorated, modern, and convenient. We especially loved the screened-in porch and cozy kitchen.

FAQs

How much does this cottage cost compared to others in Chincoteague Island?

The average price for a rental in Chincoteague Island is $341 per night. This rental is $16 above the average.

Is parking included with this cottage?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!! . For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this cottage?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!! . Enjoy the water!

Is Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!! pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this cottage is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!! ?

We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Chincoteague Island

Explore all rentals in Chincoteague Island

9.9

Outstanding(199 Reviews)

PET-FRIENDLY! Just Steps To Famous Chincoteague Pony Penning & Carnival Grounds

House

in Chincoteague Island

6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths

Garden · Pool · Pets allowed

Enjoy the best of Chincoteague Island in our House, PET-FRIENDLY! Just Steps To Famous Chincoteague Pony Penning & Carnival Grounds. A stunning property with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.

$$$$

Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!!

Cottage in Chincoteague Island, VA

Reasons to book

About this cottage rental

Amenities

Map of Chincoteague Island, VA

Nearby attractions

Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!!

Cottage in Chincoteague Island, VA

Reasons to book

About this cottage rental

Amenities

Map of Chincoteague Island, VA

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this cottage cost compared to others in Chincoteague Island?

Is parking included with this cottage?

Is there a pool at this cottage?

Is Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!! pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Cozy island cottage with a Key West flair - CLOSEST TO THE BEACH!!! ?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Chincoteague Island

Chincoteague Island travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations