Did not live up to expectations based on others reviews. Limited breakfast. Small cramped shower in our room which wS the Eluzabeth room.

We liked just about everything about the property. Parking was a bit challenging, but manageable. Breakfast was good. Happy hour was a nice touch. We also got a great beach recommendation.

Staff were so friendly and the rooms are so pretty. Had a wonderful stay

The property is very well located for those wishing to walk to all of St. Augustine’s historic highlights. The staff was very nice, the room very good, but the overall condition of the property was a bit tired.

The inn is beautiful though it needs alittle attention.The rain gutters are growing trees, the outside and porch need to be powerwashed, replace the deck chairs as almost all of them had uneven legs and breaks and the tableclothes were never changed and were quite soiled. the room itself was clean an comfortable but needs a deep clean once a month or so. very dusty on hardwood floor in corners and under bed. The service provided by annie was spectacular. she was very accomodating to all of our needs. The breakfast was very good but they only offer three different meals on a rotation. The owner is very nice but seems a bit scared. it just needs a little attention to details. the book in the room had been full for some time so i purchased a new book and left it there. perfect location, very quiet. Very much enjoyed our stay

The room was comfortable and the breakfasts were delicious. We were able to walk to the old town and attractions - no driving!!!!

Ann the housekeeper was wonderful, she made us great breakfasts each morning.The overall outside could do with a coat of paint. We never met the owner which would have been a nice idea.

Loved the location, easy walk to everywhere! Very nice covered deck for afternoon reading and eating yummy breakfast.

Booked this Victorian B & B as it looked tradition the city and decent value I liked it enough, my wife not so much We knew it was an old house but the bedroom Ed seemed a little cluttered and musty in parts. However, it was comfortable enough Decent breakfast each morning and free parking were a bonus

Good location to be in historic district

It was wonderful, highly recommended.

Great place to stay if you want to do anything in St Augustine. Great breakfast and a quiet happy hour on the porch. Staff was outstanding. Will surely come back.

Penny Farthing was charming. Ann was especially attentive to my girlfriend who has a gluten sensitivity. It’s in an excellent location.

Absolutely enjoyed our stay in this historic location walking distance to everything. Great breakfast every morning and beautiful home to enjoy during our stay in St Augustine. Plus on premise Kitty cats a plus!

Beautiful and quaint bed & breakfast within walking distance to historic Saint Augustine. It’s our second time staying here and we would definitely stay here again.

We've stayed here 4 times now. Location couldn't be better, staff is welcoming, breakfast is delicious.

Very old and well maintained.

This is our second time at the inn, the staff is amazing and friendly. We stayed in the Tree House Room and have already made reservations to return. It is easily walking distance from nearly everything you would want to see. Lovely place

Quaint, charming B&B with wonderful staff and breakfasts.

Enjoyed our 2 day stay for a wedding we attended. Kaeli was friendly and accommodating. 2 great breakfasts. 1 Heads up ... narrow driveway. large SUVS will have difficulty getting in and backing out of driveway

This was very relaxing. Great location near all the historic locations. The owner was awesome (very polite). We will stay here again !

We had a lovely one-night stay, and would definitely book Penny Fathing Inn again in the future. Charming old B&B with fabulous hosts.

We have stayed here twice and the service and atmosphere are by far our favorite thing! Its within 5-10 min walk from downtown st aug. The breakfast is amazing!

Great location. Clean. Quiet. Well decorated. Friendly. Everything you would want in a stay somewhere.

Great location withing walking distance to everything we wanted to do in St. Augustine. April was very attentive and friendly. The breakfast was excellent. The York room was great since it was bottom floor and easy access.

We had an amazing stay. It is very quiet, quirky with "English" decor. The staff was wonderful. The property was very clean and decorated nicely.

Everything

Wonderful setting and location. 5 minutes away from shopping and dining. Terrific, friendly staff. Our only drawback is parking. Some patrons have brought their oversized vehicles and their is only a couple inches of clearance on both sides of our vehicle leaving the parking area. Our rental vehicle sustained scratches from the shrubbery due to the oversized vehicles in the parking area. Parking is meant for compact vehicles and not trucks and large SUV's. Loved the place but we will not return due to the parking situation.

Cute b&b. Yummy breakfast. Convenient to walk to attractions, food, etc.

Very nice Victorian house in good condition. House could use a power wash to brighten up the yellow paint. Breakfast was very good. Between 4-5 they had complimentary wine with a few snacks put out. This was nice after an afternoon of seeing the sights. Back stairs to 2nd floor need lighting at night. Room was very nice as was bathroom. Our patio had a swing that was fun to sit and pass the time.

The house and room were beautiful. The staff were kind. It was our first time staying here. We usually have stayed next door and love jonathan. The lighting switches in the room are in weird places. We would definitely stay here again.

Great location. The owner and employee were both very friendly. I would highly recommend.