It was a nice and spacious family room. Very nice views and windows. The only issue was that no service after 5 pm.

Great bed and breakfast feel. Very clean and well kept. Staff was friendly and our stay was excellent.

Quaint and quiet. Slept well!

Wonderful family room.

Arrived at 2am after a delayed flight, had advised hotel this was happening.. wasn’t happy when no one answered the door after we rang front phone as advised for 30 minutes in the rain.. in saying that the bed was very comfortable and everything was immaculate

The Kildonan Lodge worked out well for our stay in Edinburgh. It's approximately 15 minutes from the City Centre. We used the local bus system to get back and forth and there is a stop wthin a few steps of the hotel. Parking is hard to find and is expensive in the City Centre. Our room was on the lower level, so we did not hear too much traffic noise. The room was clean and it did have a couple of USB ports for us to charge our phones (Canadian) so we did not have to use our converter. Breakfast was great and ready right on time. You preorder the night before advising of time and food choices. Checkin was easy and staff were friendly and helpful. We hired a car to get to the airport which was about a 30 minute drive.

Perfect location for exploring Edinburgh. Staff was great and helpful. Breakfast was generous.

Overall the hotel was a convenient location to stay at. Without a car the bus stops to and from the city were almost out front and 2 pound single fares was wonderful. However minor problems were apparent during the stay. There is no lift ( although the staff did assist happily ). Our TV wasn't hooked to the antenna thus no inroom tv ( although there is a large screen tv downstairs in the lounge ), when there was a large number of people in the breakfast room the meals were mixed up or incorrectly served. The large ( and very thick ) tartan drapes were ripped and there was a tassel hanging from the bed lamp. But i would stay there again as it seems the pluses outweigh the negatives

This was the most awesome place. My family loved it. We had been on vacation for 11 days at this point and stayed in many different locations and we all stated to one another we would have just stayed at this location the whole time. It's perfect. It was spacious, clean, had books, board games, an additional "sun room" with dining table. Two large beds, smaller table to eat at as well. I highly recommend.

Dint recieve vip wine and rooms been poorly finished / painted.

Great 2 night stay. Booked last minute.

Really quaint place. Room very spacious with comfy king size bed and pillow. Bus stop outside door so need to bring car into city centre 20 mins. max. Friendly and helpful staff. Breakfast was very good. Car parking on site.

We had a lovely stay at the Kildonan Lodge which was great value for money. Our room was spotless and very quiet so we had a great nights sleep. The decor is a little bit dated and shower isn’t the most powerful but for the price we paid we thought it was great value for money. Lewis who worked on reception was so friendly and went out of his way to give us recommendations. The location is perfect with a 10 minute bus journey to the old town or half an hour walk. We also walked to holyrood park which only took 20 minutes. For a hotel with free parking and in such a good location I would highly recommend.

Excellent and peaceful location. Wonderful sleep

Everything about this stay was wonderful, best cooked breakfast I’ve had possibly ever! Louis the head waiter was awesome, so friendly & helpful, the bed was very comfortable & we stayed downstairs to watch the massive tv by the honesty bar which cd be stocked up more, we will be coming back! Thank you so much! ☺️

Great breakfast, lovely house but a little tired. Staff were excellent.

We were greeted by a large overflowing cigarette butt holder alongside the front steps and check-in took twenty minutes as the receptionist, despite being very courteous, was not capable of dealing with the five pairs of guests arriving at the check-in time with Fawlty Towers being referred to by one couple! Our room in the attic was not what was expected and unheated. The poorly fitting sash windows covered by curtains which most probably were new thirty years ago and not falling apart then were stuck partially open. The number for night service remained unanswered and the heating was not repaired as promised the following day. A fan heater had to be requested as none had been provided. The hot water eventually arrived in the en-suite basin after three-four minutes minimum of waiting. The young Scottish front of house gentleman at breakfast despite being courteous and very helpful struggled to cope with incorrect breakfast orders from kitchen staff despite pre-ordering the meals the previous evening. It makes little sense as to how that is possible? From our experience- which may well be different to others-the new owner of the Guest House has much to do in order to maintain its previous Reviewer ratings. We will return to Edinburgh as we enjoyed what this unique city has to offer and the very approachable and helpful locals. We will not, however, even consider this property. Expedia have not shown due diligence with reference to this listing

Good size room, a bit aged. Facilities can be improved or repaired.

Really good location for getting in and out of Edinburgh. Clean, big rooms and attentive staff. Maybe needs a bit of updating in terms of decor but can't fault it otherwise.

Thos is a real character property - if you want immaculate and regularly refurbed, it's not for you. However, if you like a grand drawing room to relax in, beautiful Victorian original architectural features, high ceilings and extremely comfy beds, it is. Lewis, the house manager, is great, and will help you make the most of your stay. You're a 25 minute walk from the centre, but there are regular busses, and the free carparking is the upside.

This was not a luxury property. We received 1 terry cloth towel, each, and that was the only towel we received during our 3 day stay. Even when our room was serviced, we didn't receive fresh towels, or a hand towel or face cloth. The bathtub faucet was broken and the room was hot during the entire stay. Staff was OK, but certainly didn't go out of their way to make our stay memorable. I wouldn't recommend

Very old building; super old stained carpet. Room size and bed were good, as was breakfast.

Lovely small hotel, clean and comfortable, very charming room. Excellent breakfast. Friendly and helpful staff. Highly recommend!

Ideal positioning, great transport links which complemented very good public transport. Hotel was excellent, breakfast choice and service was very good Rooms were a good size with a large en-suite. My only gripe and one that would stop me returning is the fact that the mattress was incredibly firm to the point of being uncomfortable. Obviously this is my preference and may not bother others.

Very friendly and attentive service. There was everything that we needed. Room felt cold at times but with these energy prices I can understand.

Friendly helpful staff, clean and well appointed furnishings. Room clean and comfortable. Breakfast was good with excellent service. Would stay again.

I really loved this property. My main reason for choosing it was that it looked decent and was close to the event I was attending. However, I didn't expect how beautiful it was going to be and how much character it would have. I will definitely return here!

It was perfect for what I needed. Would definitely stay there again.

Our stay was amazing. Very welcoming, friendly staff. Lovely comfortable room. The breakfast was delicious. Would stay again.

The staff, food, and accommodations were wonderful! Very very very kind! Only issue was very intermittent Internet

Hotel staff great, very friendly and helpful. Food delicious . Bedroom is very comfy and clean. Would stay here again . Highly recommend.

The property was exactly as described. We found it very comfortable and the location was great for us.