On the app it looked really high end, what a disappointment. Entered room to a musty smell. Looked clean. Bathroom toilet seat dirty and broken, towel rail all askew, no bath mat and shower curtain too long bad slip and trip hazard. No bedside unit just an empty space. No where to plug kettle in. If you manage to plug hairdryer in mirror is blocked by tv. Good points parking, soft towels. Wouldn’t stay again or recommend.

This place is just really dated and poorly lit outside and the tv did not work... they did try to fix but not able too the bathtub is very unsafe and we were on the top floor with no lift...

This place is just really dated and poorly lit outside and the tv did not work... they did try to fix but not able too the bathtub is very unsafe and we were on the top floor with no lift...

Very kind clerk

Very kind clerk

It was a nice and spacious family room. Very nice views and windows. The only issue was that no service after 5 pm.

It was a nice and spacious family room. Very nice views and windows. The only issue was that no service after 5 pm.

Great bed and breakfast feel. Very clean and well kept. Staff was friendly and our stay was excellent.

Great bed and breakfast feel. Very clean and well kept. Staff was friendly and our stay was excellent.

Quaint and quiet. Slept well!

Quaint and quiet. Slept well!

Wonderful family room.

Wonderful family room.

Arrived at 2am after a delayed flight, had advised hotel this was happening.. wasn’t happy when no one answered the door after we rang front phone as advised for 30 minutes in the rain.. in saying that the bed was very comfortable and everything was immaculate

Arrived at 2am after a delayed flight, had advised hotel this was happening.. wasn’t happy when no one answered the door after we rang front phone as advised for 30 minutes in the rain.. in saying that the bed was very comfortable and everything was immaculate

The Kildonan Lodge worked out well for our stay in Edinburgh. It's approximately 15 minutes from the City Centre. We used the local bus system to get back and forth and there is a stop wthin a few steps of the hotel. Parking is hard to find and is expensive in the City Centre. Our room was on the lower level, so we did not hear too much traffic noise. The room was clean and it did have a couple of USB ports for us to charge our phones (Canadian) so we did not have to use our converter. Breakfast was great and ready right on time. You preorder the night before advising of time and food choices. Checkin was easy and staff were friendly and helpful. We hired a car to get to the airport which was about a 30 minute drive.

The Kildonan Lodge worked out well for our stay in Edinburgh. It's approximately 15 minutes from the City Centre. We used the local bus system to get back and forth and there is a stop wthin a few steps of the hotel. Parking is hard to find and is expensive in the City Centre. Our room was on the lower level, so we did not hear too much traffic noise. The room was clean and it did have a couple of USB ports for us to charge our phones (Canadian) so we did not have to use our converter. Breakfast was great and ready right on time. You preorder the night before advising of time and food choices. Checkin was easy and staff were friendly and helpful. We hired a car to get to the airport which was about a 30 minute drive.

Perfect location for exploring Edinburgh. Staff was great and helpful. Breakfast was generous.

Perfect location for exploring Edinburgh. Staff was great and helpful. Breakfast was generous.

Overall the hotel was a convenient location to stay at. Without a car the bus stops to and from the city were almost out front and 2 pound single fares was wonderful. However minor problems were apparent during the stay. There is no lift ( although the staff did assist happily ). Our TV wasn't hooked to the antenna thus no inroom tv ( although there is a large screen tv downstairs in the lounge ), when there was a large number of people in the breakfast room the meals were mixed up or incorrectly served. The large ( and very thick ) tartan drapes were ripped and there was a tassel hanging from the bed lamp. But i would stay there again as it seems the pluses outweigh the negatives

Overall the hotel was a convenient location to stay at. Without a car the bus stops to and from the city were almost out front and 2 pound single fares was wonderful. However minor problems were apparent during the stay. There is no lift ( although the staff did assist happily ). Our TV wasn't hooked to the antenna thus no inroom tv ( although there is a large screen tv downstairs in the lounge ), when there was a large number of people in the breakfast room the meals were mixed up or incorrectly served. The large ( and very thick ) tartan drapes were ripped and there was a tassel hanging from the bed lamp. But i would stay there again as it seems the pluses outweigh the negatives

This was the most awesome place. My family loved it. We had been on vacation for 11 days at this point and stayed in many different locations and we all stated to one another we would have just stayed at this location the whole time. It's perfect. It was spacious, clean, had books, board games, an additional "sun room" with dining table. Two large beds, smaller table to eat at as well. I highly recommend.

This was the most awesome place. My family loved it. We had been on vacation for 11 days at this point and stayed in many different locations and we all stated to one another we would have just stayed at this location the whole time. It's perfect. It was spacious, clean, had books, board games, an additional "sun room" with dining table. Two large beds, smaller table to eat at as well. I highly recommend.

Dint recieve vip wine and rooms been poorly finished / painted.

Dint recieve vip wine and rooms been poorly finished / painted.

Great 2 night stay. Booked last minute.

Great 2 night stay. Booked last minute.

Really quaint place. Room very spacious with comfy king size bed and pillow. Bus stop outside door so need to bring car into city centre 20 mins. max. Friendly and helpful staff. Breakfast was very good. Car parking on site.

Really quaint place. Room very spacious with comfy king size bed and pillow. Bus stop outside door so need to bring car into city centre 20 mins. max. Friendly and helpful staff. Breakfast was very good. Car parking on site.

We had a lovely stay at the Kildonan Lodge which was great value for money. Our room was spotless and very quiet so we had a great nights sleep. The decor is a little bit dated and shower isn’t the most powerful but for the price we paid we thought it was great value for money. Lewis who worked on reception was so friendly and went out of his way to give us recommendations. The location is perfect with a 10 minute bus journey to the old town or half an hour walk. We also walked to holyrood park which only took 20 minutes. For a hotel with free parking and in such a good location I would highly recommend.

We had a lovely stay at the Kildonan Lodge which was great value for money. Our room was spotless and very quiet so we had a great nights sleep. The decor is a little bit dated and shower isn’t the most powerful but for the price we paid we thought it was great value for money. Lewis who worked on reception was so friendly and went out of his way to give us recommendations. The location is perfect with a 10 minute bus journey to the old town or half an hour walk. We also walked to holyrood park which only took 20 minutes. For a hotel with free parking and in such a good location I would highly recommend.

Excellent and peaceful location. Wonderful sleep